The Best Women’s 15kg Budget Olympic Weightlifting Bars

By | 2018-05-11T17:51:04+00:00 May 12th, 2018|Categories: Equipment Guides|Tags: , , , , , , |0 Comments

 

CONTENTS

  1. Intro
  2. What Makes a Good Women’s WL Bar
  3. The Bars
    1. Rogue 25mm Training Bar
    2. York 32003
    3. Rep Gladiator
    4. Fringe WL Bar

I – Intro

This is for women’s olympic weightlifting bars (often called WL bars for short) that are best for doing the clean and the snatch. 

With the rise of women doing olympic lifting in Crossfit, and other female lifters incorporating olympic lifts into their existing routines, and just more women lifting barbells in general, more and more women are in search of bars that are more appropriate for them than the traditional power bars in most traditional gyms. Men’s WL bars also aren’t the best, because the shafts are thicker than optimal for women’s hands.

Olympic weightlifting bars are used frequently at olympic lifting gyms, Crossfit boxes, the Olympic Games or anywhere that lifters may be doing olympic lifts. They are made to be springy at high loads to facilitate explosiveness, prevent a high shock load for the lifter, and absorb the shock of being dropped. 

It isn’t necessary to get a $500-1000 bar just to have a good tool for olympic lifts. Bars in that range are typically IWF certified bars, which carries a huge bump in the price tag reflecting the cost of IWF certification. Plus, those bars are normally not appropriate for anything but practicing a few heavy singles, because the knurling is meant to really grab onto your palms to help you get the barbell up for that one heavy lift that really counts. For learning the lifts and doing regular workouts, you’re better off with a medium knurling that won’t eat up your hands.


II – What Makes a Good Women’s Olympic Weightlifting Bar

Weightlifting bars typically have a number of attributes that separate it from any number of other bars you might encounter.

More Flexible Steel

A good flex facilitates the “whip” desired for pulling heavy cleans off the floor. It makes for a smoother lift off the floor, the way the bar begins to bend upward, ever so slightly, until you pull hard enough that it completely lifts up. This is not noticeable until you get over 300 lbs or so and have done cleans on a WL bar and power bar to feel the difference. With heavier and heavier weights, the difference is huge. A power bar gets really hard to do cleans with.

The second factor in the flex is catching the bar on your shoulders in a clean. With good form the impact on your shoulders is minimal. You can test this yourself at very light weights. Load a couple 25s on, do a messy power clean by catching the bar hard on your shoulders, and it will shake, relieving the impact. Do this with a stiff 30mm power bar and you can see what I’m talking about right away. Which do you prefer? Yep, now you can never go back.

The third point at which the flex helps is bouncing out of the hole as you catch in a full squat clean. The bar tips flex down with you and whip back up as you push yourself out of the hole. Powerlifters specifically do not want this flex, because their squats are slower and any whip will be too fast for them and throw them off. They need a slow, controlled squat that may take a few seconds to complete.

High Tensile Strength Steel

Nowadays it isn’t hard to find tensile strengths over 200,000 PSI (pounds per square inch). In years past that was considered extreme and quite rare.

That isn’t to say that you have to get over 200,000 PSI. Bars well under that should not bend either. Moderately priced bars are all made to hold up to frequent drops with bumper plates onto rubber flooring or a platform. That’s quite a shock load, but it’s not nearly as bad as dropping a bar on the safety pins of a rack, which is likely to bend any bar (or the safety pins – something has to give). 

When we talk about bending, we’re talking about a permanent bend, effectively rendering the bar useless or at least extremely annoying to use. Flex under load is normal and is part of what saves the bar from developing a permanent bend. Along with high tensile strength, that’s what keeps the shaft going strong.

The steel formulations today are better for high tensile strength bars for olympic weightlifting, basically so that you can get a high tensile strength bar that isn’t super stiff because of it. 

Snap Rings or Roll Pins to Secure the Sleeves

Good WL bars have the end sleeves secured with either a snap ring (also called a retaining ring) or a pin hammered through a hole going the width of the sleeve, which is the method York Barbell in particular prefers. Most everyone besides York does the snap ring method.

One of these methods is to ensure the sleeves don’t break loose and fall off the bar after enough drops with bumper plates. Dropping a bar is tough on it, even on 3/4″ rubber flooring. Good bars can hold up fine. On the cheapest bars, usually sold for around $100 or included in a 300 lb weight set, you’ll find an allen bolt, which you need an allen key (hex key) to tighten. And tighten it you will. These are notorious for coming loose over time. Even if you apply Loctite to it, it will probably just break on you. 

Snap ring on the end of a bar

Snap ring example – See the two holes on top that the special pliers hook into to pull it into place.

Medium to Soft Knurling

The knurling is the texture that cut into the shaft of the bar to help you grip it better. There’s a whole science to it and different steps involved. 

How ever the maker decides to create the knurling pattern and texture, which we don’t need to go into here, the end result needs to be that you can get a good grip without the knurling damaging the palms of your hands over many reps. 

No Center Knurling for High Rep Workouts

All bars have knurling over most of the length of the shaft. Some men’s bars have a section of about six to nine inches of knurling in the center of the bar, while others are smooth in that area. 

Women’s IWF competition rated bars are required to not have center knurling, as opposed to the men’s standard that has the center knurl required as throwback to the old one-handed snatch that nobody does anymore.

While lifters doing other movements might like the center knurling, for the olympic lifts it serves no purpose anymore but to scratch the front of your neck during cleans. For this reason, lifters concentrating on olympic lifts prefer no center knurling.

The knurling further down the bar should extend to the end of the shaft to accommodate tall users with the maximum width snatch grip, but this isn’t the case on all bars.

910mm Spaced Ring Marks

Every bar has a 1/4″ wide smooth mark in the knurling where you place your hands. IWF spaced markings are spaced for olympic weightlifting and are 910mm apart. Lifters grip in various spots depending on their body size, but the knurl marks at least provide a reference point to help them guide their hands into the right spot for them.

In recent years, many manufacturers have added IPF 810mm spaced marks as well, for a pair of “dual” marks 5cm away from each other. They just help you position your hands consistently. That’s all there is to it. 

25mm Shaft Diameter

Not to be confused with the size of the sleeve where the weights go, which is always 50mm (1.97″) on a high quality bar.

Here we’re talking about the shaft that you grip. For the optimal grip, 25mm is the best size for women’s bars. It makes for a good pulling grip for most women.

The diameter is also major factor in the amount of flex that the shaft has, which is very important for cleans. See the info further above on flex.

Sensitive and Smooth Rotation

How sensitively and easily the sleeves spin is very important for olympic lifts so you can transition between the pull and the catch without tweaking your wrists. 

Manufacturers like Eleiko have settled on up to 10 needle bearings per sleeve for their very best competition bars. 

For budget WL bars you don’t need that many. Fewer bearings will reduce the spin, as will a combination of bushings and bearings, but it’s still good.

Bronze bushings are the next step down. Some WL bars we feature below have bronze bushings. Lubricated bronze slides well against steel (I think it has something to do with the dissimilar materials, such that bronze actually slides against steel better than steel-on-steel does). 

Shaft Finish

The finish, or outer coating, applied to a bar makes a difference in its durability, tackiness, rust resistance, and how well it holds chalk.

Chrome
Chrome plating looks nice and wears well from repeated banging on a rack. It is also the most resistant to corrosion among all bar finishes, with the exception of stainless steel. The disadvantage of chrome is it is more slippery when wet from sweaty hands.

Black Oxide
This is a thin coating that feels almost like bare steel. It’s thin enough that it doesn’t fill in any of the depth of the knurling like chrome or zinc plating does. It also gives a better grip than chrome. And it helps prevent rust (anti-corrosion), but the anti-corrosion properties of black oxide are activated by oil, so you have to oil it once in a while. It scratches more easily than other finishes, so a bar used in a rack will immediately show signs of use from the metal-on-metal contact. It can also wear off simply from the abrasion of your hands against it over time.

Black Zinc
Like black oxide, it provides a good grip and prevents corrosion without the need to oil it as much. Zinc plating has a certain thickness to it, so it does fill in the knurling slightly like chrome does, making the knurling a softer feel. Zinc itself is a bright silverish color and the black coating is actually applied over the bright zinc. 

Weight

Women’s olympic weightlifting bars are made to weigh 15kg / 33lb. There are 35lb women’s bars out there, but here we focus on the 15kg ones. There are more and more women doing barbell work, but at this point a 35lb women’s bar is still a specialty item and not justifiable by most manufacturer’s in addition to a 15kg bar. 


III – THE BARS

These four women’s WL bars are in the affordable price range of $200-400 and are suitable for beginner and intermediate lifters who don’t need a competition level bar.

Too pricey? If your #1 priority is a 25mm bar and you don’t care about the strength or sleeve spin, see the Rage Phoenix 2.0 Women’s Bar.

Rogue 25mm Women’s Training Bar

Shaft Diameter: 25mm Center Knurling: No
Shaft Finish: Black Zinc Ring Marks: IWF
Tensile Strength: 190,000 PSI Sleeve Surface: Grooved
Sleeve Spin: Bronze Bushing Made In: USA
Knurling Feel: Medium Weight: 15kg

Rogue’s 25mm Training Bar uses the same 190,000 PSI steel shaft as all their other men’s 7ft bars. That makes production a little easier!

While not nearly as popular as their Bella Bar, this one is more appropriate as a WL specific bar.

Rogue stands behind their products, and you know they’ll be around for years to come. It’s one reason people often go for Rogue when in doubt.

Plus, Rogue makes their bars in their own facility in Columbus, OH. That makes it the only one on this page made in the USA.

It’s also the only bar here with bronze bushings. So this is questionable as a pure WL bar. Bronze bushings are only one step down from needle bearings, better than composite bushings as far as the sensitivity of the spin, if it’s constructed nice and tightly and lubricated right. If you’ve used a good bronze bushing bar and you’re ok with it as a WL bar, this could be a really good choice for you.

Price: $305 at Rogue

York 32003 Women’s Elite Training Bar

Shaft Diameter: 25mm Center Knurling: No
Shaft Finish: Satin Chrome Ring Marks: Dual
Tensile Strength: 190,000 PSI Sleeve Surface: Smooth
Sleeve Spin: Bushing Made In: Canada
Knurling Feel: Medium Weight: 15 kg

The second-best women’s WL bar that York makes! The top one is priced over $500.

Not quite USA made. It’s made in Canada using US steel, like all their Elite series bars.

York Barbell has been involved in olympic weightlifting since their inception in 1932. They revised their bars a year or so back without changing the model numbers. For this one they added dual ring marks and new end caps.

From the close-up shot you see York’s patented split-sleeve design. Dead giveaway it’s a York bar when you see that.

Price: $398 at Adamant Barbell

Rep Fitness Women’s Gladiator Bar

Shaft Diameter: 28mm Center Knurling: No
Shaft Finish: Hard Chrome Ring Marks: Dual
Tensile Strength: 205,000 PSI Sleeve Surface: Grooved
Sleeve Spin: 5 Bearings Made In: USA
Knurling Feel: Medium Weight: 15 kg

Rep Fitness does not make their women’s version of the Gladiator bar with a stainless steel option. That’s ok, it’s still a great chrome plated bar!

Plus, 5 needle bearings per sleeve… That’s 1 more than Fringe (below).

Rep Fitness has been in business in Denver, Colorado (10 miles from Rage Fitness) since 2012, and they have earned the respect of the Crossfit crowd with their high quality equipment.

Rep has always had favorable reviews online and are good with answering questions. Rep’s equipment seems to be nearly as high quality as Rogue. Rep isn’t a “budget” option that cuts any corners.

Rep’s prices for larger orders are particularly competitive vs some others who offer free shipping on all sized orders. On small orders Rep normally isn’t as competitive, although in this case for a stainless steel WL bar they’re basically the only choice in this price range! If you’re in the market for additional stuff like bumpers, once you get one or more pallets worth of stuff you’re taking advantage of the fact that you’re paying actual shipping costs instead of a padded amount added to all products for “free” shipping on single-product orders. 

Price: $219 at Rep Fitness

FringeSport Women’s Weightlifting Bar

Shaft Diameter: 25mm Center Knurling: Yes
Shaft Finish: Matte Chrome Ring Marks: IWF
Tensile Strength: 216,200 PSI Sleeve Surface: Grooved
Sleeve Spin: 4 Bearings Made In: Taiwan
Knurling Feel: Medium Weight: 15 kg

This bar is the #1 women’s bar that Fringe makes for olympic weightlifting. All their other bars are made for either powerlifting dual-use. This one is their only bar with 4 needle bearings per sleeve, IWF-only ring marks, and it has the most whip out of all their bars despite the ultra high 216,000 PSI tensile strength.

As far as the “matte” chrome… I don’t think that there is any difference between matte chrome and satin chrome, which is what York calls it. The word “matte” has gotten to be a popular buzzword with Rogue and others, with their popular matte finishes on power racks, etc, and the “Matte Black Friday” sale. Basically a less glossy chrome that looks more like stainless steel. As if it weren’t already hard to tell the difference! Mirror-like chrome is one thing, but when they start using this satin chrome I have a hard time identifying what it is on an unknown bar.

Fringe’s guarantee is the best in the industry. It’s more than just a warranty against defects. They offer a full 1-year guarantee. Return it for any reason within a year and get your money back! Or within 30 days they’ll even pay the return shipping. 

Price: $399 at FringeSport

 

Got any questions about these bars? Leave a comment and I’ll see if I can help!

About the Author:

David Kiesling
David founded Adamant Barbell in 2007 and Two Rep Cave in 2018. Lately he spends his free time practicing archery and hang gliding.

Share Your Thoughts

avatar
  Subscribe  
Notify of

Latest Discussions on Two Rep Cave

Eleikos’ “Power Lock”, I.e. “Russian” bar is currently on sale for $200 off their regular price. Werksans’ entire site, although down today, is 50% off. Good luck.

American Barbell Cerakote Mammoth Power Bar: 29mm Cerakote coated Stainless Steel shaft. $550...

31mm power bar with cerakote: https://wright-equipment.com/collections/mens-20kg-olympic-weightlifting-barbells/products/45lb-mens-power-barbell

Thor power bar from rogue fitness - cerakote shaft at 29MM. https://www.roguefitness.com/rogue-athlete-power-bar-thor-edition